The Greyhound-Data Forum has been created to act as a platform for greyhound enthusiasts to share information on this magnificent animal called a greyhound.
Greyhound-Data reserve the right to remove any post that is off topic, advertisements or opinions they consider to be offensive.
If you answer then please try to stay on topic. It's absolutely okay to answer in a broader scope but don't hijack posts by switching to something off topic.
In case you see an insulting post: DO NOT REPLY TO IT!
Use the report button to inform the moderators so that we can delete it.
Grant Thomas Australia (Verified User) Posts 11447 Dogs 64 / Races 20 11 Nov 2010 04:04
(0)
(0)
grant thomas wrote:
Asked on another site I suggested a saturation of Wee Sal...??? Any thoughts...??? She and of course S.S. are responsible for the fastest and arguably the best sire in a life time.
Ray Brown Australia (Team Member) Posts 6226 Dogs 8 / Races 5 11 Nov 2010 05:18
(0)
(0)
Thanks for all the replies...actually, the mating wasn't my suggestion , it was the bitches owners decision. David, I gave him your list of suggestions too, but alas, he chose to go his own way, and why not I suppose, it looks OK to me. Your top pick MOGAMBO looks a good one also.
Anthony Jeffress (Verified User) Posts 5885 Dogs 25 / Races 122 11 Nov 2010 10:37
Happy to help out if the Owner ever decides to try something like that ... And I do see where you're coming from on this one, John.
The Wad
Daryl Annells Australia (Needs Verification) Posts 4706 Dogs 1 / Races 0 11 Nov 2010 18:22
(0)
(0)
grant thomas wrote:
grant thomas wrote:
Asked on another site I suggested a saturation of Wee Sal...??? Any thoughts...??? She and of course S.S. are responsible for the fastest and arguably the best sire in a life time.
myself personally, i would forget saturating with WEE SAL. balanced on each side yes,....over supplied on both sides no.
it appears the many attempts to over capatalise on WEE SAL has led to many genetic complications. yes there will always be an example of some success, but talking with breeders who used this thesis for a few generations, the most outstanding problem was 'breakdowns' most agreed there was speed there.it shows up as young teens really setting the tracks on fire, for the 400mtr mark mainly, then they just die.
a lot of breakdowns were being recorded. so many different bitches, but that saturation was showing up...it can only lead to one answer...it dont work.
my own experiences vindicate the breeders theories, as i have a WP bitch...very quick, very injury prone....the rest of the litter, very quick young, injuries, now even balanced performers.
when you study them closely and compare notes with the breeders, the blame sits fairly with the saturation of WS.
just my experiences and i wouldnt be looking for a sire with her in it if my dams side already had two or more bits on her side...you will be disappointed in time.
daz
Thomas Barrett Ireland (Verified User) Posts 1077 Dogs 16 / Races 1 12 Nov 2010 06:35
Adam Jones Australia (Verified User) Posts 2275 Dogs 0 / Races 1 12 Nov 2010 15:12
(0)
(0)
I wouldn't bother to double up Wee Sal, it's had it's chance and hasn't proven successful (it's gotta be a worry to many, as even though it's been tried and hasn't worked, there is many MANY more people yet to do it) and i'm talking about the doubling of the WEE SAL DAMLINE not the doubles of BDC and BRETT LEE, they may work because of using 2 superfast dogs, I doubt the double of WEE SAL in those matings will be the driving force, the fact she had no Temlee blood making her a virtual "outcross" to his (temlee) blood was the driving force in that (WS) line IMO. I'd be more inclined to try a sire like HOTSHOT (if you can find a straw) to try and re-ignite what worked in the past.
Imagen having a bitch from this mating these days, now that's a dream mating.... CLICK HERE I'd be looking at this if you could find one (there's stil a couple around...) CLICK HERE
Seeing as this bitch isn't from the WS damline I wouldn't "not do it" if the opportunity arises, but I doubt the double WS will have a great part to play in any success.
Black shiraz line over BDC bitches will work in the future, it's a "certainty" for me, BDC bitches are more valuable then Brett lee bitches IMO Time will tell on that one though.....
Ryan Vanderwert Australia (Verified User) Posts 1801 Dogs 6 / Races 0 12 Nov 2010 20:08
(0)
(0)
DARYL ANNELLS wrote:
........... it appears the many attempts to over capatalise on WEE SAL has led to many genetic complications.............lot of breakdowns were being recorded. so many different bitches, but that saturation was showing up...it can only lead to one answer...it dont work............ .............when you study them closely and compare notes with the breeders, the blame sits fairly with the saturation of WS.
daz
Daz, it's v/difficult for me to reasearch the failures unless you have the experience or know of others that do, as you say.
Just wondering if you cld list a few w/out going to too much trouble. I just wanted to chk those peds out for myself the way I look at breeding.
Thx in advance. Ryan.
Graeme Beasley Australia (Verified User) Posts 3265 Dogs 27 / Races 5 12 Nov 2010 21:09
(0)
(0)
Ryan, you'll find that many didn't make the track and were not named. Try Shirly's Rose as an example.
Grant Thomas Australia (Verified User) Posts 11447 Dogs 64 / Races 20 12 Nov 2010 22:30
(0)
(0)
Ryan Vanderwert wrote:
DARYL ANNELLS wrote:
........... it appears the many attempts to over capatalise on WEE SAL has led to many genetic complications.............lot of breakdowns were being recorded. so many different bitches, but that saturation was showing up...it can only lead to one answer...it dont work............ .............when you study them closely and compare notes with the breeders, the blame sits fairly with the saturation of WS.
daz
Daz, it's v/difficult for me to reasearch the failures unless you have the experience or know of others that do, as you say.
Just wondering if you cld list a few w/out going to too much trouble. I just wanted to chk those peds out for myself the way I look at breeding.
Thx in advance. Ryan.
here's a few that ' over capatalised ' but don't know of ' genetic complications or lot of breakdowns '
Special ancestors i.e. Wee Sal duplicated ( it won't copy & paste)
Daryl Annells Australia (Needs Verification) Posts 4706 Dogs 1 / Races 0 12 Nov 2010 22:38
(0)
(0)
Graeme Beasley wrote:
Ryan, you'll find that many didn't make the track and were not named. Try Shirly's Rose as an example.
ooohhh, that nwill hurt dave.
we are talking about brood hopefully...not there racing careers. i think, and dave or lawrence can correct me as they own SHIRLYS ROSE, SHE HASNT BEEN MATED AS YET?
but there mother and grand mother is the line in question; MALAGRO SAL....AWESOME SAL.... these created the laurels winner, MAUREEN SHIRLY, who visited WHERES PEDRO on 2 occassions. this gave you the double of WEE SAL....now if you want to go to any son of BRETT LEE for an arguments view, would then be increasing WEE SAL to 3 lines of her......if its not working with two, you wouldnt be looking for another strain.
this would happen with any daughters of AWESOME SAL wanting to go to service.(my case ANN SHIRLY)
Originally i was keen to get an outcross for this line, as i really believed it needed a 'kick along'...the choice originally would have been PREMIER FANTASY or KIOWA SWEET TREY.
along came COSMIC RUMBLE with his SPIRAL NAKITA influence, but alas another strain containing WEE SAL...so in my case i wouldnt use any son of BRETT LEE or any sire that had the WEE SAL strain involved.
so the daughters of these matings (WP X MAUREEN SHIRLY or ANN SHIRLY) need, in my opinion to outcross as hard as possible to try and weaken over a few gnerations the WEE SAL influence.
there are probably heaps more ryan, but as this one is close to home, we used this as a good example.
daz
Graeme Beasley Australia (Verified User) Posts 3265 Dogs 27 / Races 5 12 Nov 2010 23:13
(0)
(0)
I've only spoken with Dave once or twice and hopefully he'd understand that I only used that breeding as an example and not as a bitch that had the above issues. He freely admitted to us that the double didn't work due to health problems, which is more than could be said for others who try to hide faults in their line. Obviously the breeding had ability but there's more to breeding than that.
It's something I had wanted to try since we bought this bitch CLICK HERE as a 3 month old pup but Dave's comments made me wary and I thank him for them. I'll still do the double but they'll be a few generations removed and with a sire and dam that were not outwardly showing signs.
Lance Day Australia (Verified User) Posts 864 Dogs 16 / Races 1 12 Nov 2010 23:22
(0)
(0)
Here is a good double up with a third line cross of Sobbing Sal and her litter sister Hot Show Belle.Tickabond. CLICK HERE
Grant Thomas Australia (Verified User) Posts 11447 Dogs 64 / Races 20 12 Nov 2010 23:35
(0)
(0)
Lance Day wrote:
Here is a good double up with a third line cross of Sobbing Sal and her litter sister Hot Show Belle.Tickabond. CLICK HERE
He's 1 that come sup on the search i posted.
Special ancestors i.e. Wee Sal duplicated
David Deguara United Kingdom (Team Member) Posts 958 Dogs 81 / Races 93 13 Nov 2010 09:29
(0)
(0)
Lance/Grant
I think the reason why the Wee Sal double may have worked with TICABOND was the fact that it was through sister's as opposed to simply doubling up on Sobbing Sal, let's not forget, Hot Show Deb whilst never really attracting the attention that Sobbing Sal does was a fine brood bitch in her own right. Factor in the other "strong" bloods such as Gun Law Osti (Brett Lee), Black Shiraz, Thai Magic, and Head Honcho and you have a mighty good balance, something that perhaps with other "double ups" may not have been the case...either that or just damn good luck.
Being closely associated with TICABOND, I might be biased, but I can honestly say that the best of the dog was never seen (I know it is an over used comment), his brother, BONDTURE, after winning his Maiden first up, had to be euthanized at his 2nd start (Lismore), he could have been anything.
Whilst no "champions" the following were/are handy dogs with the Wee Sal double up - Wonderous, Ess Bee Dee, Arvo's Breeze, Arvo's Chill, but as we have established, there aren't too many.
Ryan Vanderwert Australia (Verified User) Posts 1801 Dogs 6 / Races 0 13 Nov 2010 21:55
(0)
(0)
david deguara wrote:
Lance/Grant
I think the reason why the Wee Sal double may have worked with TICABOND was the fact that it was through sister's as opposed to simply doubling up on Sobbing Sal, let's not forget, Hot Show Deb whilst never really attracting the attention that Sobbing Sal does was a fine brood bitch in her own right. Factor in the other "strong" bloods such as Gun Law Osti (Brett Lee), Black Shiraz, Thai Magic, and Head Honcho and you have a mighty good balance, something that perhaps with other "double ups" may not have been the case...either that or just damn good luck.
exceptionally well put David. btw EBD looked like being able to take that next step into the superdog category on a couple of occassions, I had him running a racetime post to post which was 2 lengths off velocette at his best.
I think the wee sal cross bred 'correctly' is well worth a try. fwiw.
Dave Lonergan Ireland (Verified User) Posts 3410 Dogs 18 / Races 0 13 Nov 2010 22:01
(0)
(0)
i did something similar my self Ray...definitely worth a shot.... sal might be best brood of all time anywhere heres mine EXTERNAL LINK
Grant Thomas Australia (Verified User) Posts 11447 Dogs 64 / Races 20 20 Nov 2010 12:44
Kevin Robinson United Kingdom (Verified User) Posts 363 Dogs 0 / Races 3 20 Nov 2010 22:48
(0)
(0)
Bloody mind reader 'Dix' lmao!....so is it a 'Go'... not over keen myself. Hell of a lot going on there! I really like balance,but often think I am too conservative, but would really like opinions...again sorry to go off topic