Michael, Let me speak from a distance. The example you quote has been repeated many times by errant dogs moving across to NZ and then succeeding. It is also consistent with humans (who need some incentive to do well) and by animals which have an urge or a prey drive, especially greyhounds. A reward is essential. GRV and GRNSW have been bashful about publishing results of trials or actual races. RQ (actually QGRA at the time) have not. In both SA and Qld the stats showed that results were better with the FOL fewer FTC or Fighting penalties. (My personal opinion is that dogs generally get a better view of the (high) lure and so chased the lure rather than the pack). The hooped lure generally appears to be an improvement in that it tends to encourage the field to separate a bit (this needs serious analysis which is not available). Therefore, the use of FOL and hooped lure should be standard everywhere in Oz no exceptions. The precise detail and design appears to be less important or not important at all. After all, greyhounds are bred to chase all sorts of moving prey, not just a fluffy rabbit or a coloured handkerchief. The last statement is supported by the fact that, while NZ has a universal FOL practice, there are two or three different lure styles in use at their seven tracks, including some without a hooped lure. The idea of providing a particular style of lure, or the FOL, to suit individual dogs is not a practical one. Neither are different types at different tracks. It also begs the question of whether the subject dogs have been educated on one or the other. If all pups use the same standard then problems should be minimal. Equally, to prefer the use of the pen is an argument not supported by the evidence. In other words, all the available evidence says that the FOL facility is by far the most critical feature, and that it is directly related to hard chasing. Anything else is small beer, or is related to clean running or track design rather than chasing. What dog A or B or C want or are alleged to want is neither here nor there. At the moment, there is a landslide vote in favour of the FOL.
|